This diner that boasts "24/7 Home Cookin'" is on North Walnut Street, in the same block as Black Mercantile and the Brothers bar. It's a doorway that took me a second look to find. I haven't spent a lot of time in this area for the last thirty years... no more bar life for me since then, and it is right across the street from the Bluebird. "24/7" must mean some great late night business, especially since the demise of the downtown Waffle House. Well now that it is thoroughly established that I am ANCIENT, here goes....
Once you find the door, there are a couple of easy steps or a ramp to enter, yay! for accessibility. Inside there are plenty of tables at floor level and booths one step up. We were immediately greeted by Tanner (based on our receipt - I did not miss the "Hi, I'm Tanner, let me sit down with you and tell you all my secrets while I am your server" greeting that seems to be standard these days). We picked a booth and he came right over for a drink order. I was on water tonight, having been fully caffeinated earlier, and K ordered a Pepsi, so it's a Pepsi product place. We needed to wait for our third party member and we examined the menu and chatted. Tanner let us alone, but was attentive when G arrived and got her drink order and didn't balk at her "plain hot water" (I was tempted to make fun of her a little bit). You know I have issues, though.... when he delivered her drink, he held it by the edges of the cup, not the handle... and even G, (who does not have my issues!) felt the need to wipe the edges a little bit. SERVERS, seriously, you handle money and dirty dishes and credit cards, don't hold glasses and cups by the parts people drink from!!
We ordered dinner with about 17 extra requests.... I'm no bun, no apples, dressing on the side, high maintenance. I am happy to report that even the request to have no apples on my salad, but have them served on the side. so G could eat them was respected. I didn't ask about cross contamination, except to ensure the salads were made fresh and that the apples wouldn't be "picked off" an existing salad, but I feel like reasonable requests would probably be honored. Readers, lemme know so others with food preferences or sensitivities can get a good grip on that. It was hard to make a choice because the menu is appealing, offering breakfast, sandwiches, and entrees "hot plates" all the time. I had heard that B-Town Diner has great pancakes, but there were so many offerings we passed them up this time. There seem to be several dishes available that would suit vegetarians, didn't check super well for vegans, but the menu is online at their site, so you can check before you go.
My I-have-to-wash-my-hands-now-because-I touched-the-menu visit to the bathrooms followed. The Diner has two bathrooms, both marked unisex, and both seemed large enough for a wheelchair or walker to enter. There is still a throw-back that one has a urinal and the other has a baby changing table, but with the unisex signage at least the Diner isn't enforcing gender roles. I am all for unisex or non-gendered bathrooms and the Diner seems friendly that way. Both appeared clean and well stocked as far as towels, soap, tp....
I am glad I went to dinner with friends with whom I had a lot to talk about.... the food took half an hour to arrive. When it came the salad looked huge, great and fresh, and the hot food seemed hot, except the fries. I know it's hard to time fries when there are lots of dishes served, but they really seemed like they were dropped too soon and had spent significant cooling time. Even lukewarm they tasted good. I'd like to try them when fresh! Between the three of us we ordered: fish and chips, zucchini potato pancakes, a bacon cheeseburger (no bun), and the cranberry pecan salad (apples on the side). It was a lot of food, and even though I ordered the salad instead of the fries with the burger I didn't even touch it, but packed it up for tomorrow's lunch. While we were eating and chatting some more Tanner was attentive at filling our drinks and bringing some little bits and pieces as requested. K had ordered a side of the macaroni and cheese and it didn't make it out until the end of the meal. He admitted he had forgotten to put it on the original order and gave it at no charge. The fish of the fish and chips looked like it might have been frozen breaded fillets... The menu says home cookin' and I know that doesn't always mean the same thing it used to, but those sure didn't look like freshly breaded fish to me. Also that was the ugliest presentation... a plain plate with three brown fish fillets and brown fries... a lemon wedge, a dollop of tartar sauce, an orange slice, or even some parsley would have really improved that. The presentation of the zucchini potato pancakes wasn't any better, but the colorful plate helped a little bit.
As we wound down realizing we weren't going to eat everything Tanner was quick to bring boxes as requested. I am looking forward to that salad for lunch tomorrow!
I need to note that I chose to visit B-Town Diner this week because it is spring break for I.U. Tonight we had no trouble finding parking, even though we had to pay, even the garage that has three free hours at times needed payment tonight. There was no wait for seating, but I wonder that a usual Thursday night as classes are winding down for the week is probably much busier. There was even what looked like a band bus parked over at the Bluebird tonight, but not the usual crowd milling around downtown on a not-too-cold evening. It seems like on a slow night like this the food would come more quickly, and the fries would have been able to be well attended and be hot. I understand that when I.U. is not in session normally a lot of employees are also gone and businesses often run low on crew. It should be remembered though that even non-students try to frequent downtown eateries and local businesses and deserve hot fries.
All in all, we did enjoy the diner. They could definitely improve timing and presentation. I'd like to try it again and get those pancakes. I guess the semester will be over in a few weeks and we might get there again.
This was my bunless burger. It usually would come with fries, but I asked to substitute the salad. That kind of harmed the usual presentation, I guess, but this just seems wrong.
This is the fish and chips, again with the presentation, and I wonder about that fish, even though G said it tasted okay.
This is the zucchini potatoe (oh look, my fingers typed a Dan Quayle potatoe, I think I will just leave that for atmosphere) pancakes. Really tasty, served with applesauce and/or sour cream. A nice new thing to try!
The cranberry pecan salad, sans apples, Nice and fresh and def huge, could be an entree or served family style to the entire table as a side.
This is my burger up close, NICE real bacon, sliced thick, and real cheddar.
The apples from the salad served on the side by request. They looked super fresh, plentiful, and bright. Unfortunately, I cannot taste them :( and G took them home for later.




